ELCSA slams Nkandla report

As media has reported already last week, for instance the Mail and Guardian, the Police Minister of South Africa has filed a report on Nkandla, where he concludes that President Zuma does not need to pay back any money. All upgrades were necessary, says Police Minister Nathi Nhleko.

Now our Lutheran Church, ELCSA, has issues a statement. It reads:

The Evangelical Lutheran Church in Southern Africa (ELCSA) in her 130th Church Council sitting dated 1st – 3rd June 2015 would like to add its voice in condemnation of the defensive stance as reflected in the Police Minister Nathi Nhleko’s Nkandla Report that absolved President Jacob Zuma from repaying any money for the security upgrade to his home.

We slam Nhleko’s report which contradicts the findings of Public Protector Thuli Madonsela and we want to categorically state that it is shocking and a grave mockery of justice. Failure of the President and the relevant ministers to own up to the unjustifiably high costs of the upgrades damages the moral integrity of the whole governing system.

As states by the SACC we believe that the review of the Public Protector’s report should have been conducted by a competent independent body or arm of government and not by a minister who serves the whim of the Office being investigated.

As a Church we also appeal to all citizens to unite across political, social, economic and religious persuasions to hold all of us who are in positions or influence accountable.

“We will continue to pray for the government to be directed in the ways of justice, honesty, peace and dignity for all”.

We can not sit back and condone that the Visitor’s Centre, the amphitheatre, the cattle kraal and chicken run and the swimming pool are security related. How the Minister has arrived at the conclusion leaves us with more questions than answers. Our view point does not discount the fact that we appreciate the need to protect the President and his family; however the costs incurred to date are exorbitant and have cause public outrage.

We urge the Minister and President Zuma to own up and take the citizens of this Country seriously by owning up and implement the recommendations of the Public Protector.

Bishop M M Ditlhale, Presiding Bishop

It is good. Maybe also brave. I see some signs that churches in South Africa are reclaiming a prophetic role. I welcome that.

Presently I attend a conference at the University of the Western Cape, where the Anglican Archbishop Thabo Makgoba also criticized the government. He said:

The ruling party fears a strong and united church.

He also asked, which I found surprising:

When do we as an ecumenical church withdraw our moral support of a democratically elected government?

Also the South African Council of Churches has spoken out an blasted President Zumas behaviour in parliament:

We are gravely concerned about the failure of the president and the relevant ministers to accept moral and political responsibility in relation to the unjustifiably high costs of the upgrades

SACC's Preseident, Siwa, said in the statement, according to ENCA.